5. Read the two sentences about the same event. Decide which one is better for a news report and explain why. The Event: A painter was working on a mural. A journalist arrived to interview him. Sentence A: The painter painted a mural when the journalist arrived. Sentence B: The painter was painting a mural when the journalist arrived. Which sentence is better? Why?

Question

Вопрос:

Фото задания: 5. Read the two sentences about the same event. Decide which one is better for a news report and explain why. The Event: A…

5. Read the two sentences about the same event. Decide which one is better for a news report and explain why. The Event: A painter was working on a mural. A journalist arrived to interview him. Sentence A: The painter painted a mural when the journalist arrived. Sentence B: The painter was painting a mural when the journalist arrived. Which sentence is better? Why?

Accepted Answer

Перевод задания: Прочитайте два предложения об одном и том же событии. Решите, какое из них лучше подходит для новостного сообщения, и объясните почему.

Sentence B: The painter was painting a mural when the journalist arrived.

Перевод: Художник рисовал фреску, когда пришёл журналист.

Why? The Past Continuous shows that the action was in progress when another, shorter action happened. The Past Simple is used for the interrupting action: arrived.

Почему? Past Continuous показывает действие, которое продолжалось в момент другого события. Past Simple используется для краткого действия, которое произошло в этот момент: arrived — «пришёл».

Ответ: Sentence B, because it correctly shows an action in progress interrupted by another action.