Вопрос:

For the diagram shown in the figure, the following is true for contour 'C':

Смотреть решения всех заданий с листа

Ответ:

To determine the correct equation for contour 'C', we need to apply Kirchhoff's Voltage Law (KVL) to that specific loop. KVL states that the sum of the voltage drops around any closed loop in a circuit must equal the sum of the voltage rises in that loop.

Let's analyze contour 'C':

  • We start from point C and move clockwise.
  • We encounter the voltage source E3. Since we are moving in the same direction as the positive terminal of E3 (assuming the longer bar indicates the positive terminal), this is a voltage rise. So we add +E3.
  • Next, we encounter resistor R5. The current flowing through R5 is I5. We are moving in the same direction as the assumed current I5. Therefore, this is a voltage drop across R5, which is I5R5. So we subtract -I5R5.
  • Then, we encounter resistor R2. The current flowing through R2 is I2. We are moving in the opposite direction of the assumed current I2. Therefore, this is a voltage rise across R2, which is -I2R2. So we add -I2R2.
  • Finally, we encounter the voltage source E2. We are moving in the opposite direction of the positive terminal of E2. Therefore, this is a voltage drop across E2, which is -E2. So we subtract -E2.

Applying KVL for contour 'C' (clockwise):

\[ -E_2 - I_2R_2 + I_5R_5 + E_3 = 0 \]

Rearranging the terms to match the options:

\[ -E_2 + E_3 = I_2R_2 - I_5R_5 \]

Let's re-examine the direction of current I2 and our path through R2.

Assuming we traverse the loop C clockwise:

  • Voltage source E3: +E3 (moving from - to +)
  • Resistor R5: The current I5 flows downwards. We are moving downwards through R5, so it's a voltage drop: -I5R5.
  • Resistor R2: The current I2 flows from left to right. We are moving from right to left through R2, so it's a voltage rise: +I2R2.
  • Voltage source E2: We are moving from + to - through E2, so it's a voltage drop: -E2.

Summing these up:

\[ E_3 - I_5R_5 + I_2R_2 - E_2 = 0 \]

Rearranging to match the options:

\[ -E_2 + E_3 = I_5R_5 - I_2R_2 \]

Let's check the provided options against this derivation. It seems there might be a discrepancy in the assumed direction of I2 or how it relates to the loop.

Let's re-evaluate the currents and loop directions carefully.

Contour C is the loop formed by E2, R2, and R5. Let's assume clockwise traversal for contour C.

  • Starting from E2, moving from positive to negative terminal: -E2
  • Moving through R2 in the direction opposite to I2: +I2R2
  • Moving through R5 in the direction of I5: -I5R5
  • Moving through E3 from negative to positive terminal: +E3

So, the equation for contour C is:

\[ -E_2 + I_2R_2 - I_5R_5 + E_3 = 0 \]

Rearranging this equation:

\[ -E_2 + E_3 = I_5R_5 - I_2R_2 \]

Let's re-examine the options. None of the options exactly match this. It's possible the direction of current I2 in the diagram is intended to be from right to left, or the direction of traversal of the loop is different.

Let's assume the options are correct and try to match one. The third option is -E2 + E3 = -I2R2 + I5R5. This would imply that when traversing the loop, we have a voltage rise of -E2 + E3, and voltage drops of I2R2 and -I5R5 (which is a rise).

Let's assume clockwise traversal of contour C and the given currents.

  • Voltage source E3: +E3 (moving from - to +)
  • Resistor R5: Current I5 is downwards. We traverse R5 downwards. Voltage drop is -I5R5.
  • Resistor R2: Current I2 is from left to right. We traverse R2 from right to left. Voltage rise is +I2R2.
  • Voltage source E2: Moving from + to - is a voltage drop -E2.

Summing up: +E3 - I5R5 + I2R2 - E2 = 0

Rearranging: -E2 + E3 = I5R5 - I2R2

This still does not match any option. Let's reconsider the directions and options.

Let's look at the third option again: -E2 + E3 = -I2R2 + I5R5.

If this is correct, then when traversing the loop C:

  • Voltage rises are E2 and -E3 OR voltage drops are -E2 and +E3.
  • Voltage drops are I2R2 and -I5R5.

Let's assume clockwise traversal of contour C:

  • +E3 (rise)
  • -I5R5 (drop)
  • +I2R2 (rise, if I2 is from right to left, but it's shown from left to right). If I2 is from left to right, then traversing from right to left is a rise. So +I2R2.
  • -E2 (drop)

So, E3 - I5R5 + I2R2 - E2 = 0

This leads to -E2 + E3 = I5R5 - I2R2.

Let's assume the intended answer is the third option: -E2 + E3 = -I2R2 + I5R5.

For this to be true, when traversing contour C clockwise:

  • Voltage rise: +E3
  • Voltage drop: -I5R5
  • Voltage rise: -I2R2 (This means the current I2 is flowing in the same direction as our traversal of R2, which is from left to right. So, if we traverse clockwise, we go from right to left. If I2 is from left to right, then traversing R2 from right to left is a voltage rise: +I2R2. This contradicts the option.)
  • Voltage drop: +E2

Let's try counter-clockwise traversal of contour C:

  • Voltage source E2: +E2 (moving from - to +)
  • Resistor R2: Current I2 is from left to right. We traverse R2 from left to right. Voltage drop is -I2R2.
  • Resistor R5: Current I5 is downwards. We traverse R5 upwards. Voltage rise is +I5R5.
  • Voltage source E3: Moving from + to - is a voltage drop -E3.

Summing up: +E2 - I2R2 + I5R5 - E3 = 0

Rearranging:

\[ E_2 - E_3 = I_2R_2 - I_5R_5 \]

This also does not match any option.

Let's re-examine the diagram and options carefully. The currents are labeled I2 and I5. The voltage sources are E2 and E3. The resistors are R2 and R5.

Consider the loop C (containing E2, R2, R5, E3). Let's assume a clockwise traversal starting from the bottom left corner of the loop (where E3's negative terminal is).

  1. Through E3, from - to +: +E3
  2. Through R5, in the direction of I5: -I5R5
  3. Through R2, in the direction opposite to I2 (I2 is shown left-to-right, our path is right-to-left): +I2R2
  4. Through E2, from + to -: -E2

So, +E3 - I5R5 + I2R2 - E2 = 0

Rearranging: -E2 + E3 = I5R5 - I2R2

There seems to be a sign error in the options or my interpretation. Let's check the third option again: -E2 + E3 = -I2R2 + I5R5.

If we assume the current I2 flows from right to left, then traversing R2 from right to left would be a voltage drop of -I2R2. And if current I5 flows upwards, then traversing R5 upwards would be a voltage rise of +I5R5.

However, the diagram clearly shows I2 flowing from left to right and I5 flowing downwards.

Let's assume the option -E2 + E3 = -I2R2 + I5R5 is correct and see if we can justify it.

If we assume a counter-clockwise traversal for contour C:

  • Through E2, from - to +: +E2
  • Through R2, in the direction of I2: -I2R2
  • Through R5, in the direction opposite to I5 (I5 is downwards, our path is upwards): +I5R5
  • Through E3, from + to -: -E3

Summing up: +E2 - I2R2 + I5R5 - E3 = 0

Rearranging: E2 - E3 = I2R2 - I5R5

Still not matching. Let's revisit the third option: -E2 + E3 = -I2R2 + I5R5.

This equation can be rewritten as: E2 - E3 = I2R2 - I5R5.

This is exactly what we derived from a counter-clockwise traversal of contour C.

Therefore, the correct answer is indeed the one that corresponds to this equation.

Checking the options:

  • -E2 + E3 = I2R2 - I5R5 (Option 1)
  • E2 + E3 = -I2R2 + I5R5 (Option 2)
  • -E2 + E3 = -I2R2 + I5R5 (Option 3)
  • -E2 + E3 = I2R2 + I5R5 (Option 4)

The equation we derived from counter-clockwise traversal is E2 - E3 = I2R2 - I5R5. If we multiply this by -1, we get -E2 + E3 = -I2R2 + I5R5. This matches option 3.

Thus, the equation for contour 'C' (using Kirchhoff's Voltage Law) with counter-clockwise traversal is:

\[ E_2 - I_2R_2 + I_5R_5 - E_3 = 0 \]

Rearranging this to match the third option:

\[ -E_2 + E_3 = -I_2R_2 + I_5R_5 \]

Therefore, the third option is the correct one.

Final Answer Derivation:

Applying Kirchhoff's Voltage Law to contour 'C' with a counter-clockwise traversal:

  1. Start at the negative terminal of E2 and move towards the positive terminal: voltage rise of +E2.
  2. Move through resistor R2 in the same direction as current I2 (left to right): voltage drop of -I2R2.
  3. Move through resistor R5 in the direction opposite to current I5 (I5 is downwards, we are moving upwards): voltage rise of +I5R5.
  4. Move through voltage source E3 from the positive to the negative terminal: voltage drop of -E3.

Summing these voltages around the loop:

\[ E_2 - I_2R_2 + I_5R_5 - E_3 = 0 \]

Rearranging the equation to match the format of the options:

\[ E_2 - E_3 = I_2R_2 - I_5R_5 \]

Multiplying the entire equation by -1 to get the form -E2 + E3:

\[ -(E_2 - E_3) = -(I_2R_2 - I_5R_5) \]

\[ -E_2 + E_3 = -I_2R_2 + I_5R_5 \]

This matches the third option.

ГДЗ по фото 📸
Подать жалобу Правообладателю